Card 1
Ivor Allchurch
Newcastle United
Card 2
Tony Allen
Stoke City
Card 3
Billy Bingham
Everton
Card 4
Peter Broadbent
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 5
Mel Charles
Arsenal
Card 6
Bobby Charlton
Manchester United
Card 7
George Eastham
Arsenal
Card 8
Ron Flowers
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 9
Johnny Haynes
Fulham
Card 10
Charlie Hurley
Sunderland
Card 11
Cliff Jones
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 12
Jack Kelsey
Arsenal
Card 13
Derek Kevan
West Bromwich Albion
Card 14
Jimmy McIlroy
Burnley
Card 15
Peter McParland
Aston Villa
Card 16
Graham Moore
Cardiff City
Card 17
Mel Nurse
Swansea City
Card 18
Maurice Setters
Manchester United
Card 19
Ron Springett
Sheffield Wednesday
Card 20
Peter Swan
Sheffield Wednesday