Card 1
Stanley Matthews
Blackpool
Card 2
Johnny Haynes
Fulham
Card 3
Bobby Johnstone
Manchester City
Card 4
Jackie Sewell
Aston Villa
Card 5
Dave Hickson
Huddersfield Town
Card 6
Alex Scott
Rangers
Card 7
Ron Baynham
Luton Town
Card 8
Ian McMillan
Airdrieonians
Card 9
Peter Harris
Portsmouth
Card 10
Willie Fernie
Celtic
Card 11
Harry Clarke
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 12
Ian McColl
Rangers
Card 13
Bobby Mitchell
Newcastle United
Card 14
Jim Langley
Brighton & Hove Albion
Card 15
Trevor Smith
Birmingham City
Card 16
Bobby Collins
Celtic
Card 17
Albert Quixall
Sheffield Wednesday
Card 18
Willie Bauld
Hearts
Card 19
Peter Farrell
Everton
Card 20
Don Kichenbrand
Rangers
Card 21
Ivor Allchurch
Swansea City
Card 22
Lawrie Reilly
Hibernian
Card 23
John Charles
Leeds United
Card 24
Roy Swinbourne
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 25
Jimmy Gauld
Charlton Athletic
Card 26
Gordon Smith
Hibernian
Card 27
Len Boyd
Birmingham City
Card 28
Bryan Douglas
Blackburn Rovers
Card 29
Johnny Brooks
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 30
Roy Paul
Manchester City
Card 31
Bert Trautmann
Manchester City
Card 32
Arthur Fitzsimons
Middlesbrough
Card 33
Tom Finney
Preston North End
Card 34
Jimmy Armfield
Blackpool
Card 35
Tommy Taylor
Manchester United
Card 36
Ronnie Allen
West Bromwich Albion
Card 37
Arthur Rowley
Leicester City
Card 38
Jack Kelsey
Arsenal
Card 39
Ron Flowers
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 40
Duncan Edwards
Manchester United
Card 41
Graham Leggat
Aberdeen
Card 42
Peter Sillett
Chelsea
Card 43
Brian Pilkington
Burnley
Card 44
Ray Daniel
Sunderland
Card 45
John Atyeo
Bristol City
Card 46
Vic Groves
Arsenal
Card 47
John Evans
Liverpool
Card 48
Frank Blunstone
Chelsea
Card 49
Jimmy McIlroy
Burnley
Card 50
Stuart Leary
Charlton Athletic
Card 51
Nat Lofthouse
Bolton Wanderers
Card 52
Bill Brown
Dundee
Card 53
John Higgins
Celtic
Card 54
Charlie Fleming
Sunderland
Card 55
Ted Burgin
Sheffield United
Card 56
Geoff Bradford
Bristol Rovers
Card 57
Trevor Ford
Cardiff City
Card 58
Alex Young
Hearts
Card 59
Billy Wright
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 60
Ray Barlow
West Bromwich Albion