| 24. | Matt Freese | G | |
| 5. | Antonee Robinson | LB | |
| 16. | Alex Freeman | RB | |
| 2. | Sergiño Dest | AM-R | ⮌ 72' |
| 3. | Chris Richards | CD-R | |
| 4. | Tyler Adams | RM | 🟨 59' |
| 8. | Weston McKennie | AM | |
| 10. | Christian Pulisic | AM-L | ⮌ 45' |
| 13. | Tim Ream | CD-L | |
| 17. | Malik Tillman | LM | ⮌ 82' |
| 20. | Folarin Balogun | F | ⚽ 31' ⚽ 45+5' ⮌ 72' |
Subs | |||
| 1. | Matt Turner | ||
| 6. | Auston Trusty | ||
| 7. | Giovanni Reyna | ⮕ 82' ⚽ 90+8' | |
| 9. | Ricardo Pepi | ⮕ 72' | |
| 11. | Brenden Aaronson | ||
| 12. | Miles Robinson | ||
| 14. | Sebastian Berhalter | ⮕ 45' | |
| 15. | Cristian Roldan | ||
| 18. | Max Arfsten | ||
| 19. | Haji Wright | ||
| 21. | Timothy Weah | ⮕ 72' | |
| 22. | Mark McKenzie | ||
| 23. | Joe Scally | ||
| 25. | Chris Brady | ||
| 26. | Alejandro Zendejas | ||
| 12. | Orlando Gil | G | |
| 4. | Juan Jose Cáceres | RB | 🟨 10' ⮌ 79' |
| 6. | Júnior Alonso | LB | 🟨 90+3' |
| 3. | Omar Alderete | CD-L | |
| 8. | Diego Gómez | RM | 🟨 79' ⮌ 80' |
| 9. | Antonio Sanabria | CF-R | ⮌ 62' |
| 10. | Miguel Almirón | LM | 🟨 53' ⮌ 79' |
| 14. | Andrés Cubas | CM-R | |
| 15. | Gustavo Gómez | CD-R | |
| 16. | Damián Bobadilla | CM-L | ⚽ 7' (og) ⮌ 45' |
| 19. | Julio Enciso | CF-L | |
Subs | |||
| 1. | Gatito Fernández | ||
| 2. | Gustavo Velázquez | ⮕ 79' | |
| 5. | Fabián Balbuena | ||
| 7. | Ramón Sosa | ⮕ 79' | |
| 11. | Maurício | ⮕ 45' ⚽ 73' | |
| 13. | José Canale | ||
| 17. | Alejandro Romero Gamarra | ⮕ 80' | |
| 18. | Alex Arce | ⮕ 62' 🟨 88' | |
| 20. | Braian Ojeda | ||
| 21. | Gabriel Ávalos | ||
| 22. | Gastón Olveira | ||
| 23. | Matías Galarza | ||
| 24. | Gustavo Caballero | ||
| 25. | Isidro Pitta | ||
| 26. | Alexandro Maidana | ||