Card 1
Ronnie Clayton
Blackburn Rovers
Card 2
Jim Langley
Fulham
Card 3
Jimmy Armfield
Blackpool
Card 4
Harry Gregg
Manchester United
Card 5
Danny Blanchflower
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 6
Johnny Haynes
Fulham
Card 7
Nigel Sims
Aston Villa
Card 8
Albert Cheesebrough
Leicester City
Card 9
Terry Bly
Peterborough United
Card 10
John Groves
Luton Town
Card 11
Terry Dyson
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 12
Ronnie Cope
Luton Town
Card 13
Derek Reeves
Southampton
Card 14
Jackie Mudie
Stoke City
Card 15
Jim Iley
Nottingham Forest
Card 16
Tommy Harmer
Watford
Card 17
Colin Webster
Swansea City
Card 18
Reg Davies
Swansea City
Card 19
John Elsworthy
Ipswich Town
Card 20
John Atyeo
Bristol City
Card 21
Freddie Goodwin
Leeds United
Card 22
Brian Pilkington
Bolton Wanderers
Card 23
Charlie Hurley
Sunderland
Card 24
Dave Mackay
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 25
Tony Kay
Sheffield Wednesday
Card 26
Cliff Jones
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 27
Alan Hodgkinson
Sheffield United
Card 28
George Cohen
Fulham
Card 29
Peter Dobing
Manchester City
Card 30
Allan Brown
Portsmouth
Card 31
Albert Scanlon
Newcastle United
Card 32
Alex Parker
Everton
Card 33
Bobby Robson
West Bromwich Albion
Card 34
Ronnie Allen
Crystal Palace
Card 35
Alan A'Court
Liverpool
Card 36
Edwin Holliday
Middlesbrough
Card 37
Billy Bingham
Everton
Card 38
Stuart Leary
Charlton Athletic
Card 39
Ron Springett
Sheffield Wednesday
Card 40
Dennis Emery
Peterborough United
Card 41
Ron Newman
Leyton Orient
Card 42
Stanley Matthews
Blackpool
Card 43
Stewart Imlach
Coventry City
Card 44
Alan Finney
Sheffield Wednesday
Card 45
Roy McCrohan
Norwich City
Card 46
Eddie Clamp
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 47
Ivor Allchurch
Newcastle United
Card 48
Peter Brabrook
Chelsea
Card 49
Don Howe
West Bromwich Albion
Card 50
Ray Pointer
Burnley
Card 51
John Connelly
Burnley
Card 52
Johnny Brooks
Brentford
Card 53
Bobby Charlton
Manchester United
Card 54
Bobby Smith
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 55
Johnny Gordon
Portsmouth
Card 56
Jimmy Scoular
Bradford (Park Avenue)
Card 57
Dave MacLaren
Plymouth Argyle
Card 58
Jimmy Dudley
Walsall
Card 59
Ken Leek
Newcastle United
Card 60
Brian Miller
Burnley
Card 61
Ken Taylor
Huddersfield Town
Card 62
Ian Greaves
Oldham Athletic
Card 63
Noel Cantwell
Manchester United
Card 64
Stan Crowther
Brighton & Hove Albion